Tuesday, May 12, 2009

essay 5 rough draft

Justin Sealund

Servais

English 1A

4 May 2009

            The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is controversy to say the least. Many have opposed the thought of this book being publicly taught in schools, and some have opened their doors for the book.  The main reason for which people may want the book banned is that there is an ongoing discussion of race in the novel.  Although the novel was written after the civil war and slavery was already abolished Twain still decided to set the book before the civil war. Now people do not understand this, and they generalize about him being racist since he uses the N-word excessively. The amount at which the word is used can be mistaken for being racist, however he was trying to set the novel in the correct time frame, which he did successfully. Over time the meaning of the word has changed greatly, with its ancestral meaning still shadowing the true meaning. A lot of people would agree that there isn’t anything racist about anything said until the racism is brought up. So by reading this book and understanding when it was written and the time frame it was intended; readers should disregard any racist terminology, but when people bring up the topic of racism for discussion that is when it actually becomes racist. “It is truly in the eye of the beholder.”

            Given the time frame the book was intended, people should automatically assume some racism and prejudice. Many essay writers will disapprove of Twain’s antics and criticize the time he spent on the novel. Twain spent close to nine years on this story, and it was clear after the civil war. Twain had grown up in the time of racism, and he probably never grew out of it. Justin Kaplan wrote Born to Troubles: One Hundred years of Huckleberry Finn. In his essay he has an argument to subside those of other non-believers of Twain. Kaplan argues, “In the aftermath of the concord expulsion of Huckleberry Finn Mark Twain was more certain than ever that there was no such thing as a unitary audience” (374). He is saying that the book was never intended for a certain audience. Most people will not see eye to eye on this book along with its main topics of discussion. Kaplan is saying that Twain meant for the racism in the novel to be up to the readers, and for there to be a debate on the matters of racism in the novel. Kaplan states

“There is one especially bitter irony in the career of Huckleberry Finn. This novel, a savage indictment of a society that accepted slavery as a way of life, nevertheless has come under attack in our time for its alleged ‘racism.’ In 1957, for example, the NAACP condemned the book as ‘racially offensive.’ Such charges have supported exclusionary actions taken in many other states…It seems unlikely that anyone, of any color, who had actually read Huckleberry Finn, instead of merely reading the or hearing about it, and who had allowed himself or herself even the barest minimum of intelligent response to its underlying spirit and intention, could accuse it of being ‘racist’ because some of its characters use offensive racial epithets. These characters belong in their place and time, which is the Mississippi Valley thirty years before Emancipation” ( 378.)

There are quite a few people out there just willing to make generalizations about the book being racist and a lot of them just go with what other people say. Sure it is racist now a day to use the words used in the novel, however the novel needs to be read with the thought of the time frame. Most people now just want to be on the “right side” of the racism topic, claiming to not be racist by saying “Twain was racist by using the language he did even given the time he wrote the novel.” The truth is that most people have some sort of racism in them but when the racism topic comes up they try and cover it up. There are a lot of scapegoats being pointed out.

           

 

Work cited:

Kaplan, Justin. “Born to Trouble: One Hundred Years of Huckleberry Finn.” Adventures of Huckleberry Finn: A Case Study in Critical Controversy. 2nd ed. Eds. Gerald Graff and James Phelan. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s 2004. 371-381.

1 comment:

  1. great job so far. thesis is very clear. good job on using quotes to show others arguements. lots of supporting ideas.

    ReplyDelete