Tuesday, May 12, 2009

essay 5 rough draft

Justin Sealund

Servais

English 1A

4 May 2009

            The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is controversy to say the least. Many have opposed the thought of this book being publicly taught in schools, and some have opened their doors for the book.  The main reason for which people may want the book banned is that there is an ongoing discussion of race in the novel.  Although the novel was written after the civil war and slavery was already abolished Twain still decided to set the book before the civil war. Now people do not understand this, and they generalize about him being racist since he uses the N-word excessively. The amount at which the word is used can be mistaken for being racist, however he was trying to set the novel in the correct time frame, which he did successfully. Over time the meaning of the word has changed greatly, with its ancestral meaning still shadowing the true meaning. A lot of people would agree that there isn’t anything racist about anything said until the racism is brought up. So by reading this book and understanding when it was written and the time frame it was intended; readers should disregard any racist terminology, but when people bring up the topic of racism for discussion that is when it actually becomes racist. “It is truly in the eye of the beholder.”

            Given the time frame the book was intended, people should automatically assume some racism and prejudice. Many essay writers will disapprove of Twain’s antics and criticize the time he spent on the novel. Twain spent close to nine years on this story, and it was clear after the civil war. Twain had grown up in the time of racism, and he probably never grew out of it. Justin Kaplan wrote Born to Troubles: One Hundred years of Huckleberry Finn. In his essay he has an argument to subside those of other non-believers of Twain. Kaplan argues, “In the aftermath of the concord expulsion of Huckleberry Finn Mark Twain was more certain than ever that there was no such thing as a unitary audience” (374). He is saying that the book was never intended for a certain audience. Most people will not see eye to eye on this book along with its main topics of discussion. Kaplan is saying that Twain meant for the racism in the novel to be up to the readers, and for there to be a debate on the matters of racism in the novel. Kaplan states

“There is one especially bitter irony in the career of Huckleberry Finn. This novel, a savage indictment of a society that accepted slavery as a way of life, nevertheless has come under attack in our time for its alleged ‘racism.’ In 1957, for example, the NAACP condemned the book as ‘racially offensive.’ Such charges have supported exclusionary actions taken in many other states…It seems unlikely that anyone, of any color, who had actually read Huckleberry Finn, instead of merely reading the or hearing about it, and who had allowed himself or herself even the barest minimum of intelligent response to its underlying spirit and intention, could accuse it of being ‘racist’ because some of its characters use offensive racial epithets. These characters belong in their place and time, which is the Mississippi Valley thirty years before Emancipation” ( 378.)

There are quite a few people out there just willing to make generalizations about the book being racist and a lot of them just go with what other people say. Sure it is racist now a day to use the words used in the novel, however the novel needs to be read with the thought of the time frame. Most people now just want to be on the “right side” of the racism topic, claiming to not be racist by saying “Twain was racist by using the language he did even given the time he wrote the novel.” The truth is that most people have some sort of racism in them but when the racism topic comes up they try and cover it up. There are a lot of scapegoats being pointed out.

           

 

Work cited:

Kaplan, Justin. “Born to Trouble: One Hundred Years of Huckleberry Finn.” Adventures of Huckleberry Finn: A Case Study in Critical Controversy. 2nd ed. Eds. Gerald Graff and James Phelan. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s 2004. 371-381.

Monday, May 4, 2009

essay 5

Justin Sealund

Servais

English 1A

4 May 2009

            The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is controversy to say the least. Many have opposed the thought of this book being publicly taught in schools, and some have opened their doors for the book.  The main reason for which people may want the book banned is that there is an ongoing discussion of race in the novel.  Although the novel was written after the civil war and slavery was already abolished Twain still decided to set the book before the civil war. Now people do not understand this, and they generalize about him being racist since he uses the N-word excessively. The amount at which the word is used can be mistaken for being racist, however he was trying to set the novel in the correct time frame, which he did successfully. Over time the meaning of the word has changed greatly, with its ancestral meaning still shadowing the true meaning. A lot of people would agree that there isn’t anything racist about anything said until the racism is brought up. So by reading this book and understanding when it was written and the time frame it was intended; readers should disregard any racist terminology, but when people bring up the topic of racism for discussion that is when it actually becomes racist. “It is truly in the eye of the beholder.”

            Given the time frame the book was intended, people should automatically assume some racism and prejudice. Many essay writers will disapprove of Twain’s antics and criticize the time he spent on the novel. Twain spent close to nine years on this story, and it was clear after the civil war. Twain had grown up in the time of racism, and he probably never grew out of it. Justin Kaplan wrote Born to Troubles: One Hundred years of Huckleberry Finn. In his essay he has an argument to subside those of other non-believers of Twain. Kaplan argues, “In the aftermath of the concord expulsion of Huckleberry Finn Mark Twain was more certain than ever that there was no such thing as a unitary audience” (374). He is saying that 

Monday, April 27, 2009

What isn't racist any more?

I do not think that having the image was really that racist or insensitive. However there are a ton of people out there whom of which will disagree with me. It is just an image to go with "the funky city".. just like having a image of an apple and it reads "juicy". These are hardly similar but you should get the point. The fact that they would even say that he is racist for posting that picture is simply a hasty generalization. Sure it can be racist on certain grounds, however for just posting that picture is not being racist. I suppose there is no such thing as freedom of speech anymore. So having a personal bog website, means merely to not have any type of free speech (at least for a city councilman.) The racism that stirs from this is that it was him who was in the "blackface" makeup. It is only racist since it was in spite of Barack Obama. So just simply having a image of a random black guy on his blog website would not have been nearly as bad as him dressing as a black man imitating Obama. 

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Rough Draft Essay #4

Justin Sealund

L. Servais

English 1A

April 13 2009

Development of Huck

            Huckleberry Finn is complicated to say the least. Mark Twain has made this character in the novel Adventures of Huckleberry Finn quite diverse and he can almost be traced back to how Twain acted as a child. Huck is almost bi-polar in some things that go on in his head, one moment he can be calm and comfortable with his new friend Jim, then the next he can be thinking about turning him in. Huck, if nothing else, just does not know what his priorities are; whether he should choose friendship or to “do the right thing” and turn him in and not go to hell.

            Mark Twain is portraying Huck as the juvenile whom of which has no real thought in his head. So it makes the reader take the aspect that he would not do anything with Jim out of friendship, but out of mindless rebellion. Huck being from a perfect society where he does not really have any daily troubles and where racism is still present makes his adventure even more outlandish. His parents making him do chores, which every kid dislikes, started him off on his little tangent, which grew to his large adventure. Huck is simply misunderstood and he wants to express to people how he feels. Most of the characters in the novel cannot relate to the adolescent and he must reach out for a connection to life. Jim is the one person whom Huck can rebel with because he is black, and Jim also gives him that connection to his misleading life. Huck and Jim grow on each other and become friends but Huck being from a religious background turns heads a couple times in inconclusive about turning in Jim because he is a runaway slave.

            Usually friendships are full of nice behavior towards the two or multiple people. However everyone has had a friend whom they are not really that thrilled about and they tend to be mean or have thoughts about the consideration of their friendship. 

Monday, April 6, 2009

Huck finn topic

For essay #4 I will be doing topic number 3. First of all I think of Huck being a little outcast form his almost perfect life. Although he and Tom Sawyer are little trouble makers he almost needs this little retreat with Jim. At first he might be a little frightened by Jim but in the end he becomes great friends with him. Huck eventually questions his "alliance" or friendship with jim and decides not to turn him in which shows a lot of character which I do not think Huck started with at the beginning of the novel. My thesis will be something around how Huck changes his opinion of "black people" especially Jim throughout his entire journey. My body paragraphs will be with quotes and examples of Huck talking about Jim or descriptions of how he is questioning the friendship of the two outcasts. Already read the book allows me to not have too many questions or concerns. Maybe the only concern is if I can find all the information I need. 

Monday, March 30, 2009

Satire

Satire is pretty much just making fun of other people or things with comical elements. Satire is almost always brought out within a group of friends enjoying conversation. A lot of the time the satire is from previously watched programs or movies which was found to be stupid or even childish. The friends will repeat the joke from the movie with their own twist on it, adding satire. Sometimes when the friends take a class together they can mock the teacher and what they said by adding a different voice or tone to the phrase. Online there are a lot of satirical images displaying irony. Irony being the big contributor of satire. The Superman and Barbie ads were of some satire quality. Satire is an effective way for people to realize what is wrong but they do not necessarily need to be told up front. If the point which is trying to get across to someone is told through satire then the person can laugh about it, but still know that one thing  needs to change..

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Racism, Sexism, etc.

 Over spring break I did not notice too much racism or sexism jokes or comments, possibly on the fact that I am either used to hearing them now that I do not really notice them or I just was not paying close enough attention to it. The form of Racism that is presented is mainly body language not verbal. Most people now a day are not racist up front but they do have racist thoughts or feeling about other nationalities. A lot of people, as it is pretty noticeable, hang out in little clicks and those clicks mainly consist of people of the same race. This was especially common a few years ago. There is less and less racism around today but it still exists whether we like it or not. I did not really notice any bumper stickers or random jokes that were racist or sexist over break but I was watching Oprah and the topic of Chris Brown abusing his girlfriend came up. It seems as if every time I watch Oprah or like Tyra (STRICTLY WITH THE MOMS ONLY) they seem to always be a little sexist. The Chris Brown case was that he struck her in the car after being a little slapped up himself. Although no woman should be hit, I also believe that no man should be hit by a woman either. Watching the show just seemed like Oprah and Tyra were on the girlfriends side. They would say that it is pretty  much okay for a woman to hit a man but not a man to hit a woman. So I was getting a little upset about that, but that is a mild favoritism from Oprah for women. There is not much sexism and or racism in California if not the U.S. now a day.