Monday, February 2, 2009

Tee or no Tee?

Students should have all the rights of the first amendment in life, especially in school since that is where they are most of their days. Kids of different ages act differently of course and so younger kids wearing "redneck" and Obama shirts do not really pose a huge conflict with the schools since they most likely do not know what they are doing is wrong, if it is wrong in  the first place. Now a fifth grader being turned down from wearing his Obama tee is just wrong. especially since elijah wore offensive tees in the past and never had conflict about them. What is the difference in a student promoting his president elect on a shirt and a teacher promoting a picture of a candidate in the classroom? As for the "Redneck" shirt it also should not have been banned simply because it is a graphic tee that most high-school/any age of students wear. I regard that there are some shirts which are inappropriate for school, but by banning the "Redneck" shirt  they should have to ban all shirts with words on it just because those words may be offensive to others. So the  school board has no stand on saying what is offensive and what isn't. 






4 comments:

  1. I feel the same way... it is a bit crazy that these t-shirts were banned from school.. I guess the redneck t-shirt could have been looked at as offensive (if the guy wearing it was not a redneck but he was..) As for the Obama T-shirt, the school went way to far.. That was just dumb.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree, Neither of the tee shirts posed a threat of any kind. Kids do deserve to be able to voice their opinions because it is essential in there development. If we allow the government to censor all the little things there is really no way to express individuality or creat an outlet for creativity.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that the schools definitely should be able to censor clothing that is truly offensive, but in both cases, the schools were in the wrong. The redneck shirt was worn as a joke, not to be offensive, and the Obama shirt was in no way offensive or distracting, and should not have been banned either.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think the fifth grade boy should be allowed to wear his shirt it was offensive or disruptive. I think the school board should be more concerned about education than what students can and cant wear.

    ReplyDelete